Menu

the cat:

two quantum

enigmas

We could imagine that in reality the atom (and hence the cat) is in a precise ‘decayed/not decayed’ (‘alive/dead’) state at all times, and that, in our ignorance, we can only find this out by taking a direct reading. Until this moment of measurement, we somehow mask our ignorance by pretending that the system is simultaneously in two distinguished states, though in reality we know that this is not really the case. The function describing the state of the system during the observation process would, therefore, not collapse to one of the possible states, but simply reveal explicitly the state in which the system was, prior to measurement. Albert Einstein thought something similar – a thought encapsulated in his dictum “God does not play dice with the universe”.

In conventional physics, this is indeed the case. The results of a given experiment are always certain, at most it is we who are unable to define the parameters of the system well enough. In the latter case, we conceal our ignorance with the concept of probability. Let us consider, for instance, the tossing of a coin. We all know that the probability of getting ‘heads’ is fifty percent, but if we could know exactly from what height the coin is tossed, with what force, at what exact point this force is applied, etc. we could predict the result with great certainty. Pierre-Simon, marquis de Laplace imagined the most disturbing consequence of such a world: Laplace’s demon, a being who knows the position and speed of all the particles in the universe. Through the laws of conventional physics, it would be able to predict precisely and decisively the entire past and future of the world; nothing could surprise it or escape its calculations.

In truth, the matter is much more complex, and there are experiments in which an interpretation in these terms of quantum mechanics leads to erroneous predictions. Without going into too much detail, we can simply say that the experiments show interference effects between the different coexisting states prior to the measurement, so we have to accept the fact that, prior to observation, the system is not in one precise and well-defined state. This implies that there is no certain prediction of what the state of the system will be once measured. In some ways, God actually does play dice with the universe, implying that probability is inherent in quantum systems. Probabilistic statements in the quantum field are ‘irreducible’, they do not reflect our ignorance. Laplace’s demon seems to be vanquished by an unpredictability inherent in nature itself.

And yet, is the atom really simultaneously decayed and undecayed before we measure it? There are different answers to this question, corresponding to different interpretations of quantum mechanics. According to the ‘Copenhagen’ interpretation – one of the most widely accepted among scientists – the question is ill-posed because science can only study what is detectable and observable, thus the question of what happens before measurement is meaningless.

However, there is another interpretation, equally legitimate, known as the ‘many-worlds’ interpretation. According to the proponents of this interpretation, there are two universes: one in which the decay of the atom with the consequent death of the cat takes place, and another in which the opposite scenario takes place. Basically, whenever a quantum system is at a crossroads, it takes both possible paths, and the universe somehow splits into two universes with opposite scenarios. This is where a more modern version of Laplace’s demon returns. When faced with a quantum experiment, it knows exactly all the possible outcomes and knows that they will all come true, each in a different universe. Therefore, the demon is able to predict with certainty not only the future of the universe in which it finds itself at that moment, but also of all the universes that will branch off from it.

Share on facebook

Facebook

Share on twitter

Twitter

Share on linkedin

LinkedIn

Share on email

Email

Hi! We use the thirds cookies to your navigation experience are better. Accept privacy policy

Privacy & Cookies Policy

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.